Discussion Topic: "Employers should have the right to electronically monitor employees as much as they choose. If employees don't like it, they should quit." Discuss your position on this ethical issue with your group, and use some of the following questions to help direct the discussion.
|
by Sarah Hi, |
by Sarah Hi, |
by Kat Himes I agree with Mia. I have a friend who works for a major corporation, and that is how her email is inspected. |
by Susannah Erler I think that if an employer chooses to monitor their employees, then the time an employee comes to work should not be much of a factor in deciding how much to monitor them. Unless the company has detected an increase in "missing property" (for example) during a certain shift. The employee might want to monitor that shift more closely. |
by Jeremy Menard If drug tests are to be random, it seems to me counterintuitive that only one shift or level(type) of employee were forced to take drug tests. If fairness is of major importance then random selection should be applied. Or better yet, test those employees who have specific symptoms. Suspicion warrants testing. If drug testing is based upon suspicion, then the symptoms that managers look for should be posted for all employees to see. In other words, employees should be able to know beforehand what constitutes suspicious behavior. |
by Jeremy Menard I just realized that I responded to the wrong topic. Sorry about that. I will repost in the other discussion area. |
by Kat Himes Guys, |
by Mia Schybergson
|
by David Allen Hi guys. |
by Christina Waskan One could argue that you are oversimplifying the issue. But sometimes we have to do just that to help us make a decision. Especially, when there are valid arguments on both sides. But I agree with you in the sense that companies are there to make a profit. If they don't make one, they cease to exist. And then, what? In the long run, no one would benefit. |
by Chounhee Choi
|
by David Allen good point Chounhee. where do we draw the line. |
by yaron david i looked around a bit to see if there was an data that could support our contention that EM may reduce stress. as you too found- it aint out there. the point that we made, although it may not be a very strong point, is that there is lots of data that shows that if employers know the best time as to when to give out breaks, then employees' productivity and satisfaction increases, therebye reducing job related stress. now, by monitoring the employees we can find out exactly when the optimal time for a break would be. in this case monitoring is used as sort of a feedback mechanism. i don't agree that it would be necessary to continue all the monitoring once that optimal break-time is found. |
by Susannah Erler Hello Yaron and Ram, |
by Jeremy Menard Susannah, |
by Susannah Erler Hello Jeremy, |
by yaron david with regards to Ram's email: |
by Ram Muthaiyah The cases sited were leagal cases involving the employer and employee. There is another legal issue that the employer should be worried abut. For instance, I as an employee can break into IBM's computer network. This causes a legal issue for the compnay from another company. Through EM such costly lawsuits can be prevented. |
by Ram Muthaiyah
|
by Ram Muthaiyah I was in the group that argued against EM. In the debate yesterday, the FOR team, proposed certain arguments supporting EM as EM reduces stress and improves productivity. But while researching for this debate I actually found survey results stating the contrary. Are there any surveys that show EM does reduce stress and improve productiviy. |
by Susannah Erler Hello, |
by Susannah Erler I was in the group which debated for electronic monitoring. Here is one of issues which piqued my interest while researching the paper: |
by yaron david hope everybody out there got something out of the presentation today. |
by Susannah Erler I wonder about that too. I came up with a couple of possibilities: |
by Ram Muthaiyah Yes, it was a good debate yesterday. I am glad you brought up this point in this discussion as I was not too convinced in class. |
by David Allen yaron, |
by Allan Jeong ELABORATE & COMMENT ON EACH OTHER's MESSAGES: |
Create your own forum at Network54 |
Copyright © 2000 Network54. All rights reserved. Terms of Use Privacy Statement |